Statutory & Regulatory Compliance Framework for Employer-Sponsored Section 105 / Section 125 Medical Expense Reimbursement Plan (SIMERP)
- To
- Certified Public Accountant / Tax Advisor
- Date
- Subject
- Statutory Authority, Regulatory Compliance, and FICA Exclusion Rationale for Pre-Tax Medical Care Membership Reimbursement Structure
1. Executive Summary
This memorandum outlines the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) provisions, Treasury Regulations, and IRS guidance governing our Employer-Sponsored Self-Insured Medical Expense Reimbursement Plan (SIMERP) paired with an IRC § 125 Cafeteria Plan. Under this arrangement, eligible employees make a pre-tax salary reduction election to fund continuous, open-ended access to qualified medical care (such as virtual primary care, urgent care, mental health counseling, and prescription drugs) delivered via a clinical platform and administered by an independent, SOC 2 Type II certified Third-Party Administrator (TPA).
Because the arrangement funds actual medical care defined under IRC § 213(d) with zero cash payouts or indemnity rebates to employees, the elected amounts and resulting medical reimbursements are excluded from employee gross income and exempt from Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) payroll taxes for both the employer and employee.
2. Governing Statutory & Regulatory Authorities
| Code / Regulation | Legal Function in Plan Architecture | Compliance & Tax Effect |
|---|---|---|
| IRC § 125 (Cafeteria Plans) | Establishes the pre-tax salary reduction election framework, treating employee salary reductions as employer contributions toward qualified benefits. | Prevents constructive receipt of income; authorizes pre-tax payroll deductions for qualified accident and health benefits. |
| IRC § 106 (Contributions by Employer to Accident & Health Plans) | Excludes employer-provided coverage under an accident or health plan (including Section 125 salary-reduction amounts treated as employer contributions) from employee gross income. | Ensures the value of ongoing medical plan coverage and clinical platform access is non-taxable to the employee. |
| IRC § 105(b) (Amounts Expended for Medical Care) | Authorizes tax-free employer reimbursements to employees for expenses incurred for medical care (as defined in § 213(d)) for the employee, spouse, and dependents. | Protects tax-free status of benefit delivery and pay-period reimbursements when substantiated as medical care. |
| Treas. Reg. § 1.105-2 (26 CFR § 1.105-2) | Implementing regulation for § 105(b). Restricts tax exclusion to actual medical care expenses and prohibits tax-free payments made “irrespective of whether the employee incurs a medical expense”. | Permits direct or indirect payments discharging a medical care obligation while disqualifying flat-indemnity cash-back schemes. |
| IRC § 213(d) (Definition of Medical Care) | Defines qualifying medical care as amounts paid for the diagnosis, cure, mitigation, treatment, or prevention of disease, or for affecting any structure or function of the body, plus prescribed drugs. | Establishes the strict clinical boundary ensuring every dollar funded under the plan corresponds to legitimate medical services. |
| IRC § 3121(a)(5)(G) & § 3121(a)(2) (FICA Wage Exclusions) | Explicitly excludes qualified § 125 cafeteria plan elections (§ 3121(a)(5)(G)) and employer-provided § 105 medical care benefits (§ 3121(a)(2)) from the statutory definition of “wages”. | Permanently exempts pre-tax medical elections and reimbursements from Social Security (6.2%) and Medicare (1.45%) taxes for both employer and employee. |
| IRC § 105(h) (Nondiscrimination Rules) | Requires self-insured medical reimbursement plans not to discriminate in favor of highly compensated individuals regarding eligibility or benefits. | Preserves tax-favored status across the workforce via uniform eligibility and benefit tiers administered by the TPA. |
3. Core Compliance Rationale & Audit Defenses
A. Continuous Access vs. Individual Utilization (Treas. Reg. § 1.105-2)
A common CPA inquiry is whether a monthly medical membership fee remains compliant under 26 CFR § 1.105-2 if a specific employee does not utilize clinical services during a given month or plan year.
- Availability Principle: Under federal tax and healthcare principles, funding a medical plan or clinical network relies on continuous availability, analogous to a traditional health insurance premium, an Employee Assistance Program (EAP), or an employer-sponsored telemedicine subscription. The plan pays to maintain a staffed, 24/7 clinical infrastructure available to the employee. Low or zero utilization by an individual participant does not alter the medical nature of the coverage or violate § 1.105-2.
- Indirect Payment Discharge: Under Treas. Reg. § 1.105-2, payment made directly to a healthcare provider or clinical service vendor in discharge of a medical care obligation constitutes a valid indirect reimbursement to the employee.
B. Pay-Period Reimbursements & FICA Tax Reductions
When an employee elects a pre-tax salary reduction under IRC § 125 and receives a corresponding pay-period reimbursement or allocation applied directly toward the qualified medical membership:
- Statutory Wage Exclusion: Under IRC § 3121(a)(5)(G), amounts redirected via a valid § 125 election are statutorily excluded from FICA wages (unlike 401(k) deferrals under § 3121(v)(2), which remain subject to FICA).
- No Circular Cash Loop: The resulting reduction in FICA liability and increase in net take-home pay is the direct statutory consequence of IRC §§ 125, 105(b), and 3121(a)—not an artificial wage-recharacterization scheme.
C. Distinction from Flagged Fixed-Indemnity Schemes (IRS CCA 202323006 & Rev. Rul. 2005-24)
The IRS has aggressively targeted abusive “FICA-savings wellness” programs—most notably in Chief Counsel Advice (CCA) 202323006 and Revenue Ruling 2005-24. Those arrangements fail under Treas. Reg. § 1.105-2 because they pay flat, predetermined cash amounts back to employees for completing trivial non-medical tasks (e.g., logging into an app or completing a health survey) irrespective of whether any medical expense was incurred.
| Compliance Dimension | Disqualified Fixed-Indemnity Schemes (CCA 202323006) | Compliant EHP / Section 105 SIMERP Structure |
|---|---|---|
| Cash Distributions to Employees | Distributes recurring flat cash checks or wage-replacement rebates to employees. | Zero cash payouts. Employees never receive cash checks, rebates, or discretionary rewards. |
| Trigger for Benefit | Completing an administrative task (app check-in, survey) or routine zero-cost preventive screening. | Enrollment in and delivery of actual IRC § 213(d) clinical healthcare services. |
| Substantiation & Adjudication | Automated paper loop without independent clinical adjudication. | Substantiated and adjudicated by an independent, SOC 2 Type II certified TPA. |
| Underlying Coverage Requirement | Often marketed as a standalone payroll-reduction vehicle. | Operates strictly alongside qualifying major medical or ACA-compliant Minimum Essential Coverage (MEC). |
4. Mandatory Operational & Documentation Guardrails
To ensure the plan remains audit-ready and fully defensible before the IRS, the employer and Third-Party Administrator maintain the following required compliance artifacts:
- Formal Written Plan Documents: Executed IRC § 125 Cafeteria Plan document, IRC § 105 SIMERP plan document, and ERISA-compliant Summary Plan Descriptions (SPDs).
- Independent TPA Administration: All employee elections, eligibility verifications, claims adjudications, and § 213(d) expense substantiations are administered by a SOC 2 Type II certified TPA.
- Actuarial Valuation: Independent actuarial certification supporting the plan’s reimbursement structure and benefit valuation.
- Segregation of Non-Medical Perks: Any non-clinical lifestyle features (such as general gym memberships or unprescribed wellness coaching) are strictly excluded from tax-free § 105(b) reimbursement so that pre-tax funds exclusively cover qualifying § 213(d) medical care.
- Major Medical Alignment & Nondiscrimination Testing: Verification that participants maintain qualifying underlying medical coverage and annual testing under IRC § 105(h) and IRC § 125(b) to confirm non-discriminatory participation.
Disclaimer: This memorandum summarizes the applicable federal statutory and regulatory framework under the Internal Revenue Code and Treasury Regulations for informational and tax-review purposes and does not constitute formal legal or tax representation. Employers should review specific plan documents, adoption agreements, and actuarial certifications with their CPA and ERISA legal counsel.