For brokers, a rate increase is never just a number on a renewal letter. It is the moment a long-time client starts taking other meetings.

The latest research shows why those conversations are getting harder. Mercer’s National Survey of Employer-Sponsored Health Plans found that the average cost of employer-sponsored health coverage rose 6.0% in 2025, to $17,496 per employee. Mercer projects an even higher increase of 6.7% for 2026 — the highest in 15 years — which would push the average cost above $18,500 per employee.

KFF’s 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey puts the household bill in even sharper relief. The average annual premium for family coverage reached $28,303 this year, up 5% from 2025 and 28% over the past five years. Covered workers now contribute $7,471 toward family coverage, a 9% increase in a single year — nearly twice the overall premium increase, and well ahead of wage growth (3.7%) and inflation (2.7%).

Looking ahead, the pressure is not easing. Business Group on Health’s 2027 Employer Healthcare Strategy Survey found employers predicting a median 9.2% healthcare cost increase for 2027, or 8% even after plan-design changes. KFF likewise notes that early forecasts for 2027 point to increases approaching double digits.

When costs move like this, employers shop

Business Group on Health reports that 71% of the employers it surveyed are already using the request-for-proposal process to secure lower pricing. In KFF’s survey, 16% of large firms said they changed insurers or plan administrators in response to projected cost increases, and 44% of large firms raised the share of the premium their workers pay. Those are not abstract industry trends. They are the conditions under which a group you have served for years starts asking whether someone else can do better.

Renewals get contentious. Benefits committees want options. Finance leaders want a story besides “the market went up again.” If the only thing you bring to the table is a higher number, you are defending last year’s relationship with this year’s bill. That is when books of business get unstable — not because you stopped doing your job, but because the employer feels they have no new lever left to pull.

A different conversation at renewal

A $0-cost-to-employer health and wellness program, offered alongside the major medical plans you already place, gives you something to bring into that meeting that is not a takeaway. The program is powered by a health and wellness platform already used by more than 4,000 companies and municipalities and over 25 million people. Nothing about the client’s current coverage has to be replaced.

For the employer, the program can save up to $639 per enrolled employee per year. Employees typically see a net increase in take-home pay, and they and their families get everyday care with no copay when they use it: 24/7 virtual urgent and primary care, mental health support, a weight-health program, virtual physical therapy, fitness and nutrition tools, and 1,000+ generic prescriptions at $0 with home delivery. Because routine care can move off the major medical plan, the program may help stabilize premiums over time. That is not a guarantee — experience and trend still depend on the group — but it is a concrete value-add at renewal, when employers are deciding whether to stay, shop, or shift more cost onto their people.

It also changes the economics of your book. Brokers earn $20 per enrolled employee per month for as long as the group stays enrolled. You stay the broker of record. No contracting is required to make an introduction, and the program is administered for you and the employer, so you are not adding a new operational burden to an already heavy renewal season.

The groups most likely to listen are the ones already feeling the squeeze: employers with 5 or more W-2 employees, staring at another year of elevated trend, and wondering what you are going to do about it. Showing up with a program that can put money back in payroll, give employees a better everyday-care experience, and may help take pressure off future rate increases is a different conversation than defending another jump in cost.

The research is public, and your clients are reading the same headlines. The question is not whether employers will keep shopping. It is whether you are the broker who arrives at renewal with a new answer.

Sources

Mercer, National Survey of Employer-Sponsored Health Plans, and Mercer’s November 18, 2025 newsroom release. KFF, 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey, published October 22, 2026. Business Group on Health, 2027 Employer Healthcare Strategy Survey, released August 25, 2026.